Just because you're not a fan of it doesn't mean other users of the site aren't. I like to disable offers on barter while I'm unavailable for trading so it doesn't look like I'm just outright ignoring people who send offers (because it makes me come off as utterly rude by not responding to them, and then those people may not want to send me offers in the future when I am available).

This is the only site that happens on where it massively increases the size like that, and only with the one icon...

TBH, those cons don't really seem like cons to me. If they're tiny icons, the filesize to download is negligible, not even comparable to the html page itself; most half decent image editors can export as SVG, so it's no harder to modify than PNG unless you insist on trying to code the SVGs from scratch, and I have no idea how it would be "harder to maintain" unless all you're talking about is trying to get an icon that works on both light and dark backgrounds with proper transparency around the icon.

I should probably just drop it and stop replying, but to me, it sounds like you're saying you have things the way you like/want them.

Text emoji, in general, look terrible to me (sure I'm not the only one with that opinion), especially when looking at the other icons next to that blacklist one - http://i.imgur.com/uaqI8L5.png - the blacklist is just an outline (like all text emoji) whereas the others are colored and filled in, they look like proper icons. The star for wishlist and the arrows for tradables are also text, yes, but they aren't emoji, so they have a different look and aren't just outline. Matches, library, bundles, and offers all look like they're already icons, why not do the same for blacklist?

Thank you. It took me a minute to find it though - I went to the "Profile - Look and Layout" page at first and didn't see it. I guess the location of the button right now is more optimal for you since you can hit it on any page to see the differences easily.

Btw, why is the blacklist icon so massive?
http://i.imgur.com/D1vzlKm.png
It makes the vertical height of all those tabs seem way too large for the rest of them.

I didn't mean for you to drop everything and suddenly implement themes. I know CSS takes a while to get right. All I'm saying is that having site themes without requiring users to install external software or extensions is much more preferable. Obviously, the actual features of the trading and such should be done first. For now, I can definitely use an extension, but having built-in themes is a much better option. The same could be said for site features. For example, Enhanced Steam is great, I love it, but it would be better if those features didn't require the extension and they were default, built-in, Steam features available on any client.Sorry, I don't mean to be rude or come off as argumentative (even though I know I do come off that way sometimes).That comparison doesn't really make much sense though because for bundle or store sites you generally only visit them to buy something, activate your keys (or download the drm-free game), and then leave. But a trading site is more of a hub for all those purchases that is typically visited much more frequently.

Edit: Also, Steam does have a white icon made for dark backgrounds... they use it on the store page: http://i.imgur.com/sjFKaMK.png
http://store.edgecast.steamstatic.com/public/shared/images/header/globalheader_logo.png

And Twitch.tv does purple on dark just fine.

I've resisted moving over to this site until now because of the option of a dark theme available on barter and this site only being available in white, but am forced to now because of being unable to login to barter anymore.